Water Heaters

When your water heater starts acting up you could be left wondering: do I repair or replace it? Check out our newest blog for some key considerations to help make the decision process a little bit easier.

Posted by Billy | November 5, 2024

Your water heater is the unsung hero of your home, providing hot showers, clean dishes and warm laundry day in and day out. But when it starts acting up, you’re left wondering: should I repair or replace it altogether?

Deciding when to fix issues or invest in a brand new unit can be tricky, especially when trying to balance cost with long-term efficiency. In this blog, the team at Beluga Heating, Air & Electrical will help you navigate the signs that point to a simple repair versus when it’s time to say goodbye. 

Our team of experienced plumbers have been Putnam’s Country’s go to experts for everything hot water heater related. From installation options to comprehensive repair and maintenance, we’ve got you covered. Let’s dive in!

Close-up of a shower with flowing water and hot steam.


Dirty dishes soaking in a kitchen sink.


Close-up of wet clothes with laundry detergent.

Types of Water Heaters

At Beluga Heating, Air & Electrical we carry two main types of water heater: tanked and tankless.

Traditional tanked water heaters store and heat large amounts of water for later use, while a tankless model heats water on demand as it passes through the unit. Tankless water heaters tend to be more efficient, while tanked models require less maintenance and they’re usually easier to install.
Both units have their pros and cons, so call our trained plumbers today and we’ll help you find the best equipment options for your home and unique needs.

Tanked water heater boiler in the foreground.


Automatic white tankless water heater against a yellow tiled bathroom background.

Common Water Heater Issues

Inconsistent Water Temperature

Several factors could contribute to a serious lack of hot water including a faulty heating element, a malfunctioning thermostat or sediment build up in your tank. Regardless of the reason, our repair specialists can accurately diagnose the problem and fix the broken component fast!

Strange Noises 

If you hear unusual noises coming from the inside of your water heater, it could mean that sediment has begun to build up inside your tank or water lines. As water heats up, minerals in the water can settle creating a layer of sediment that could interfere with the heating element causing banging sounds

Leaks

Leaks can become common due to unchecked connection lines, corrosion or a faulty pressure relief valve. Promptly addressing leaks is essential to preventing costly system replacements, so call on our friendly team at the first signs!

Pilot Light Issues

Just like your furnace, the pilot light ignites the gas elements of your water heater, which then heats the water in your tank. Issues with the pilot light could be caused by a faulty thermocouple or gas valve. It’s important to address pilot light problems immediately to ensure safe operation.

Worried woman using her smartphone to call in a breakdown emergency service.

To Repair Or Replace? That is The Question.

Deciding whether to repair or replace your water heater can be overwhelming, we get it. But here are some key considerations that might help make the decision a little bit easier!

Age

Most water heaters, when well-maintained, can last anywhere from 10-15 years. If your equipment is nearing the end of that lifespan it might be time to consider replacing it for a newer model that meets today’s efficiency standards, and your performance ones!

But if you just installed your equipment and this is the first time you’ve encountered an issue, chances are a simple repair will do the trick!

Frequent Repairs

If you find yourself constantly fixing your water heater, the cumulative cost of repairs might justify a replacement. Not to mention saving you valuable time.

Capacity Issues

If your household needs more hot water than your current unit can provide, upgrading to a larger tank or even to a tankless model will go a long way to improving your comfort, while lowering energy costs.

When To Call In The Pros!

Any hiccup with your hot water can be a major inconvenience, but we don’t recommend you tackle them alone! For complex jobs, or to maintain safety, rest easy knowing that the experienced team at Beluga Heating, Air & Electrical is just a phone call, or click away!

24/7 Emergency Repairs

From malfunctioning components to system inefficiencies, our knowledgeable technicians have you covered. We come to you in fully stocked service trucks ready to efficiently identify and address water heater issues, big or small. 
All repair solutions are thoroughly explained and you’ll have the peace of mind knowing there will be no hidden fees or surprises with our clear and comprehensive quotes.

Comprehensive Installation Solutions

At Beluga, we specialize in providing top-notch equipment options that ensure efficiency, reliability and peace of mind. And we make it easy to get the best deal on your new equipment with flexible financing options that fit any budget. 

When paired with our continuously trained technicians and full-stocked service trucks, we guarantee to exceed your expectations.

At the end of the day, choosing whether to repair or replace your water heater depends on the type and age of your equipment, as well as frequency of repairs and capacity considerations. But no matter which way you decide to go, know that Beluga Heating, Air & Electrical is by your side.

By staying informed about common issues and knowing what to look for at the first sign of trouble, you can ensure a steady stream of hot water for years to come.
Beluga is Putnam County’s #1 choice for water heater installation, repair and maintenance. Give us a call today!

Close-up of a female hand adjusting the temperature on a modern home gas-fired water heater.

Shower with flowing water and visible steam.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does water heater installation cost?

The cost to install your new water heater depends on the efficiency, type and size of equipment you choose. Call us today for your no obligation quote.

How much does water heater repair cost?

The cost to repair your water heater depends on the type, size and condition of your equipment, call us today for your no obligation repair evaluation and recommendations.

When should I schedule my repair service?

Ensure to call us right away at the first sign of issues. Letting them linger can lead to recurring repairs and shortened equipment lifespan.

How do I best maintain my water heater?

The best way to maintain your water heater is by signing up for Beluga Heating, Air & Electrical’s Maintenance Contracts. You’ll enjoy pre scheduled, ongoing maintenance to ensure optimal performance and efficiency, and access to exclusive perks and discounts. Call us today to learn more.